Joy Kim

Librarian. Book Reviewer. Coffee Addict.

June 8, 2009
by Joy
2 Comments

Umino, Chica: Honey and Clover, vol. 4-5

hachikuro4.jpgHoney and Clover, Vol. 4-5
Story and Art by Chica Umino
Rated T+ for Older Teen
Originally published in Japan in 2000
Serialized in US Shojo Beat in 2008-2009
Published by Viz in volume form 2008-2009
ISBN-13: 978-1-4215-1507-6 (vol. 4)
ISBN-13: 978-1-4215-2366-8 (vol. 5)

Ysabet gets to review most Viz Shojo Beat titles over at Manga Life, so I’ve decided to put my comments on some of those series over here. And this weekend I began catching up on Honey and Clover, thanks my order of a couple recent volumes from Amazon.

I’m really unreasonably fond of this series, so you should probably take my gushing here with a whole shakerful of salt. But I think these two volumes both show the series hitting its stride. Both highlight the way the series is interested in more than romantic love. Yes, love is certainly a central concern, but friendship is just as important. And beyond that, the series looks at what it means to grow up, to choose a career, to be an average person in world where there are geniuses.

(Some spoilers in the rest of my comments)

Continue Reading →

June 5, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Highlights from Shojo Beat (Apr-Jun 09)

Highlights from Shojo Beat (Apr-Jun 09)

I have never been a subscriber to Shojo Beat, but I was definitely among those who were sad to hear that the July 2008 issue would be its last. I’ve read the magazine off and on at the library for the past three years, and I’ve enjoyed the early access to chapters of favorite series as well as some of its pop culture/lifestyle features. On a side note, I have never enjoyed Shonen Jump nearly as much, even though I read just as much shonen manga as shojo manga.

Shojo Beat is usually checked out at the library where I work, but I was lucky enough to find a bunch of recent issues on the shelf today. So I checked out the April, May, and June issues and settled down tonight to enjoy the latest chapters of Sand Chronicles. I’ve read volume 5 of that series already, but these are some (or all?) of the chapters that will appear in volume 6 and were thus new to me. And they were lovely.

Continue Reading →

June 2, 2009
by Joy
2 Comments

Lee, SangEun: 13th Boy, vol. 1

13thboy_1.jpg13th Boy is the story of Hee-So Eun, an eighth-grader who has been spectacularly unlucky in love. Despite her tender years, she’s already had–and lost–eleven boyfriends. So one can’t blame her for being reluctant to give up on boyfriend number 12, Won-Jun, when he wants to break up after a month of dating. After all, their relationship began with her dramatic confession of her feelings for him on national television: it must be destiny! But reigniting their romance isn’t going to be easy for Hee-So, especially with Won-Jun’s best friend Whie-Young offering obnoxious commentary on the futility of her efforts every step of the way. Continue Reading →

June 2, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Sun and Guo: The History of the West Wing

Sun and Guo: The History of the West Wing

westwing.jpgA young scholar sleeping in a temple courtyard encounters the beautiful daughter of a government official. It’s not quite love at first sight, but both parties are intrigued; before long, a clandestine second meeting is arranged. So begins The History of the West Wing, a manhua adaptation of a classic Chinese play (Xixiang Ji by Wang Shifu). Continue Reading →

May 20, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Tanigawa, Tsugana, and Ito: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, vol. 3

Tanigawa, Tsugana, and Ito: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, vol. 3

haruhi_3.jpgWhen Haruhi enters the SOS Brigade into a local baseball tournament, the club members once again find themselves scrambling to cater to her whims. Winning isn’t everything to Haruhi; it’s the only thing. And it’s up to Kyon and the others to make sure she goes home happy, lest the universe suffer the consequences. Continue Reading →

May 20, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Chmakova, Svetlana: Nightschool: The Weirn Books, vol. 1

Chmakova, Svetlana: Nightschool: The Weirn Books, vol. 1

nightschool_1.gif
Sarah Treveney has a new job as part of the staff at a high school for vampires, werewolves, and witches. For reasons not yet explained, her younger sister Alex, a talented weirn (a type of witch in the series), is not attending the nightschool and is instead being schooled at home. When Alex sneaks out one night in defiance of her sister’s orders, she has a strange run-in with a group of humans who hunt supernatural beings. And unfortunately for the Treveney sisters, that’s only the first mysterious happening of the night: the second one has even more serious consequences and sets the plot in motion for the chapters to come. Continue Reading →

April 28, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Kiyuduki, Satoko: GA, vol. 1

Kiyuduki, Satoko: GA, vol. 1

ga_v1.gifGA: Geijutsuka Art Design Class is a yonkoma (4 panel) manga that follows five friends–Kisaragi, Miki, Namiko, Tomokane, and Miyabi–during their days in a high school art department. Each strip collected in this volume captures a different moment in the girls’ lives, from the frantic rush to complete an assignment to not-so-peaceful lunches in the cafeteria. Continue Reading →

April 22, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Ishida, Akira: Oninagi, vol. 1

Ishida, Akira: Oninagi, vol. 1

oninagi1.jpgFifteen-year-old Nanami is looking forward to starting high school, since it will give her an opportunity to be closer to her long-time crush Kazuto Sanjouin. But her hopes for a normal springtime of youth are promptly derailed by the arrival of a mysterious swordswoman, Tomotaka Onogoroshi. Tomotaka accuses Nanami of being a demon and tries to kill her. And when the dust finally settles, Nanami learns things about her family history that will change her life. Continue Reading →

April 22, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Jo Walton on Lois McMaster Bujold over at Tor.com

Jo Walton on Lois McMaster Bujold over at Tor.com

Swing by the official Tor blogs when you get a chance, because novelist Jo Walton has been writing a series of posts on Lois McMaster Bujold’s Vorkosigan series. The post on Memory is especially worth reading. It really expresses a lot of my own feelings toward that book. An excerpt:

Memory (1998) is in my opinion the worst place to start the Vorkosigan saga, because it is a sequel to all the books that have gone before it. I know that by saying this I’ll be prompting several people who started with it to say that no, it absolutely hooked them, but even so, I think you will get more out of Memory if you come to it with knowledge of the earlier books, and the most if you come to it with all of the earlier books fresh in your mind. It contains some very sharp spear points on some very long spears. Memory was nominated for a Hugo but did not win, and I suspect that might have been partly because it is so very much a sequel.

(If you don’t get the reference to spear points, also read this post by Walton.)

I have heard that some readers don’t like Memory because it represents such a break from the nonstop action/adventure of the earlier books. Like Walton, I fall in the opposite camp; I believe its radical departure from the established formula is exactly what that series needed. It’s a shame but sort of inevitable that it doesn’t work as a starting point–as Walton says, it’s very much a sequel. Still, it’s the main reason I encourage readers who like but don’t quite love the early Miles books to stick with the series. It’s easily my favorite of all of Bujold’s work to date.

A question for those of my readers who are familiar with this series: Do you agree with Walton? And what do you normally recommend as a Vorkosigan series starting place?

April 14, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Huh and Kim: Pig Bride, vol. 1

Huh and Kim: Pig Bride, vol. 1

pigbride1.jpgWhen eight-year-old Si-Joon, the spoiled son of a senator, is lost in the mountains during summer camp, he meets a strange woman who tells him that he must marry her (literally) pig-faced daughter to atone for the sins of his ancestors. He stupidly agrees to participate in the wedding ceremony just so he can have something to eat. (Well, he is only eight!) It’s such a strange adventure that he grows up thinking that it was only a dream. But on his sixteenth birthday, his bride shows up in his dorm room, ready to consummate their marriage, and Si-Joon finds himself in a very awkward situation. Continue Reading →

April 7, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Yu, Yanshu: Step, vol. 1

Yu, Yanshu: Step, vol. 1

step1.jpgStep is the story of Mr. Han, a professional monster hunter, and Dynasty Tang, the orphaned vampire girl that he has taken in. When Mr. Han is not busy fending off vampires and three-headed dogs, he focuses on lighter pursuits, such as getting Dynasty Tang off to school on time and reading her bedtime stories. But Mr. Han as some secrets of his own–secrets that he’d very much like to avoid sharing with his young ward. Continue Reading →

March 20, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Urasawa, Naoki: 20th Century Boys, vol. 1

Urasawa, Naoki: 20th Century Boys, vol. 1

20thCenturyBoys01.jpgEven in the US, where most of his work is still not yet available, Naoki Urasawa is something of a manga superstar. When his work Monster, a suspenseful thriller about a doctor on the trail of a serial killer, first began to be published in the states, it was greeted by rave reviews and not one but two Eisner nominations. So it’s not much of a surprise that the publication of Urasawa’s 20th Century Boys has been accompanied by very high reader expectations. Could 20th Century Boys really be as good as Monster? Could it even be better? Continue Reading →

February 10, 2009
by Joy
1 Comment

Belated blogiversary

I’ve been so busy at work that I completely missed my blog anniversary.

When I started this blog a year ago, I was still a student, reading trashy vampire shojo manga, and annoyed by Re-Gifters.

Now I’ve graduated and work a full-time job that I love. Yay! I have not picked up any trashy vampire shojo manga lately, but I am am newly in love with the manga series Yotsuba&! And the thought of Re-Gifters still makes me want to kick things, but I don’t expect to ever change my mind on that one.

At any rate, in honor of my blogiversary, if any of the five or so readers of this blog would like me to post on a certain topic, I am happy to take requests.

February 10, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Mizushiro, Setona: After School Nightmare, vol. 10

Mizushiro, Setona: After School Nightmare, vol. 10

afterschool10.jpgThe tenth volume of After School Nightmare marks the end of the series and finally offers some answers regarding Ichijo’s mysterious experiences in the dream class. Readers who’ve stuck with this fascinating series through all its earlier twists and turns will not be surprised to discover that Mizushiro has a final shocking revelation up her sleeve. Continue Reading →

January 26, 2009
by Joy
Comments Off on Youth media awards

Youth media awards

ALA announced its youth media award winners today at the midwinter conference in Denver. I really enjoyed The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman, so I was very happy to see that it had won the Newbery Medal. Of course, Gaiman has posted about how he learned the big news in a hilarious fashion over at his own blog.

There is always a lot of talk about whether the Newbery Medal is awarded to books only librarians could love (as opposed to books that actual children could love), but this year, at least, the committee hit the sweet spot with a book that will appeal to both audiences. :)

I was also very pleased to see After Tupac and D Foster by Jacqueline Woodson receive a Newbery Honor. Woodson is the sort of author who tends to be on librarians’ radar, but this is a good one: a quiet story about the transformative friendship of three girls set during the era of Tupac’s rise and fall.

As for the Printz Award, I have to confess that I have never heard of the winner (Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta), but I have put a hold on it at the library.

January 16, 2009
by Joy
1 Comment

Sugiura, Shiho: Silver Diamond, vol. 3

silverdiamond3.jpgIn Silver Diamond, Rakan, an orphaned teen with an affinity for plants, has his life turned upside down when a series of unexpected guests from another world turn up in his garden. Chigusa arrives first; he initially mistakes Rakan for someone else, but soon realizes his error and vows to protect Rakan. Narushige and his snake companion Koh come next, bringing Rakan more information about his strange connection to their world. Finally Tohji appears on the scene, intent upon assassinating Rakan on the orders of the imperial prince of his world. As volume three begins, Rakan, Chigusa, and Narushige have captured Tohji and must decide what to do with him and, ultimately, what to do with themselves. Continue Reading →

December 30, 2008
by Joy
Comments Off on A partial “best of” list

A partial “best of” list

Manga Life has posted its end of 2008 wrap-up. I contributed a few thoughts on my favorite manga and anime releases in 2008.

Click on the link to see what I and other ML contributors cited as our favorites. I read lots of other things I loved this year, of course, but most of the others were not first released in 2008.

December 20, 2008
by Joy
3 Comments

Voice actor performances

Voice acting is one of those things I never really noticed until I started watching anime. Then I went and compared the original Japanese-language audio tracks of a couple anime to their English-language dubs and heard for myself the difference a voice performance can make. For some series, it’s not that big a deal. For example, I prefer the original Japanese language audio for Fullmetal Alchemist, but still enjoy the English language dub. But for other series, the difference is huge. There are some series that I love in their original Japanese versions that I find wholly unwatchable in their dubbed English versions. (*coughcough* Cowboy Bebop *coughcough*)

From time to time, I’ve noticed individual voice performances that have, in their own way, made a series. So here’s a Friday Five of my favorite voice acting performances in anime.

Continue Reading →

December 10, 2008
by Joy
1 Comment

Cross that off my to-watch list

avatar.jpgAvatar: The Last Airbender is a children’s cartoon that aired on Nickelodeon over three seasons. It’s the story of a fantasy world where certain people have an affinity for elemental magic. Those with the ability to manipulate one of the four elements–air, earth, water, fire–are known as benders. And one person in every generation, the Avatar, has the ability to bend all four elements and thus carries the heavy responsibility of maintaining balance in the world. In the show, the Avatar returns after disappearing for one hundred years, and the series follows his adventures as he tries to master his powers and prevent the Fire Nation from conquering all the others.

If you work with children, you are probably already familiar with the show’s premise. What you might not know is that Avatar has significant crossover appeal to older audiences. That includes yours truly. Avatar was my favorite US television over the last two years. The first season is decent; the second season is stronger; and the third season is pretty much awesome. I loved the clever storytelling, the mix of comedy and drama, and the incredibly kinetic action sequences (based on real martial arts and beautifully animated). And I also loved the show because it drew inspiration from a wide range of cultures, especially Chinese and Inuit, in a way that felt respectful rather than exploitative. All the major characters in the show were portrayed as characters of color. Given the general lack of diversity in a lot of children’s media, that was priceless.

The series finished its run over the summer, and since then, there’s been lots of talk of follow-up movies and even a live-action adaptation. Well, the cast for the live-action movie has just been announced, and it’s entirely white. What’s particularly disappointing is that the director, M. Night Shyamalan, is Asian American.

I’m pretty sure that I’m just one of many Avatar fans who has just decided not to watch this particular movie.

I encourage anyone who hasn’t watch the show to investigate it on dvd. (I checked out my copies way back when from my public library!) But give the movie a pass. With a cast like that, I very much doubt it will be able to justice to the original story.

ETA: Nojojojo has a much better post on this topic over at Alas, a blog.

December 1, 2008
by Joy
Comments Off on Hagaren miscellany

Hagaren miscellany

Via umadoshi: Jake Forbes on the joys of the Fullmetal Alchemist manga. An excerpt:

Any anime fan who’s followed the scene for the last five years is probably quite familiar with this ongoing tale of angst and alchemy, but if you’ve only experienced Fullmetal in its animated form, you’re really missing out. The manga, still going strong in Japan and the US (courtesy of Viz), diverged from the anime back in volume 9.

To which I say: Hear, hear! There hasn’t been much buzz about this series since the anime completed its US release, but it continues to be one of the best manga series available in the states. As Forbes notes, the pacing particularly sets it apart from other popular shonen series, where not much can happen for volumes at a time. I may have an incurable weakness for lengthy Shonen Jump series like Naruto and Bleach, but I freely admit that their pacing issues are often dire.

Perhaps the new Hagaren1 anime series in the works will lead to renewed interest in the manga. I confess to being quite curious about what BONES will do with the sequel series. The anime tv series and movie diverge so drastically from the original manga source that I can’t see the anime going back to the manga storyline; any new anime series will probably have a wholly original arc.

What manga series do you feel are underappreciated?

1 Hagaren, like Furuba for Fruits Basket, is an abbreviation for the full Japanese name of the series, Hagane no Renkinjutsushi.